Evaluating "breadcrumbs" layouts

Solution 2 : Combo boxes in a form

>

In this breadcrumb format, every component in the logical path is in a SELECT showing all components at the same level. With user-agent Javascript enabled, selecting an entry in any of the SELECT sends to the chosen page. With scripting disabled, buttons appear right to each SELECT to allow select then button click to the destination (using <noscript>)

Feedback to fgm@osinet.fr or in news:comp.infosystems.www.authoring.site-design , thread "Breadcrumb layouts".

Pros & Cons

PROS CONS
Shorter path: the transversal structure on links reduces path length by one Maybe less usual
Lots of choices offered on each page, allowing faster access to more points immediately, without having to wait for a page load May be overwhelming to the user
Works with or without scripting Navigation without scripting requires two clicks per jump instead of one
Works fine in IE6 and O6, probably, in anything version above O3, NN6, and IE4 Amaya 5.3 stacks SELECT vertically, even using display: inline for this element.
  Some clueless (or not caring) search engines may be unable/unwilling to follow the combination links in the form. Google allegedely only follows links based on the HREF and SRC attributes for elements supporting them. See http://www.google.com/bot.html#whatlinks

However, they don't actually say it doesn't follow other types of links...

Detail

In OSInet, a page explaining about it and showing child levels:

In OSInet / Produits et services, a page explaining about it and showing child levels (brand names)

... and so on...Compteur Audean